"Nightgown alert y'all, here it comes!' -Paige, TheDollPlace

https://the-niche.blog/2020/03/30/all-282-american-girl-doll-outfits-ranked/ I saw this post and thought "What if I ranked all the nightgowns" so here we are.

This is bad. This is really, really, really bad

What kind of orphan servant wears silk for pj's?

The other one was bad, this just looks kind of wrong. The pants and the tie at the waist are kind of historically accurate, but all 1910's pajamas have sleeves and the silk ribbon just isn't working for me

.Apparently AG went through a phase where all of the pj's were silk

Glad we've moved on

. There's just something about these that I don't like. Maybe it's because it's such a downgrade form her first ones. Maybe it's the embroidered flower is the middle. Maybe it's the zig-zag stripes. Maybe it's the flip-flops. Who knows

Sorry Molly, red is not your color, and I wish American Girl would see that

Ok, yeah this is historically accurate. But can we please take off the collar, it looks like poor Kirsten is being choked

I don't know about you, but I don't like sleeping in puffer coats. I have nothing against the color yellow. I'm wearing yellow right now. But this is a little much. Oh, and those shoes look awful

Why American Girl? Why? What is this monstrosity? I guess the headband is cute

I'll take historically accurate over whatever this is any day

I'm sorry Molly, this is not a good look for you and the dark blue with the light blue, and the ribbon, and the shoes, the way the sleeves are sewn on, not great

. Again, don't like collars, and the ribbon color is the only thing distinguishing it from Kirsten's, but it is better than the Beforever one

Out of all the nightgowns that look exactly the same, I think Josephina did it the best, mainly because she's not being strangled. Also, Beforever robbed her from the gorgeous deep red color she sported when she was Pleasant Company

Pink is not Cecile's color, and that vest is awful

The top is adorable, but the shorts kind of ruined it. Yep, they definitely ruined it.

This is the point in the list where I think the nightgowns are actually ok, and Marie Grace looks so adorable in this light green color. Why is she always wearing mint green and pink? (Because her mommy didn't like her. -Kylie, TheDollPlace) The heels nock it down a few notches though and it looks dated, but I guess that makes sense

I love this, but Kit is supposed to hate frills and pink, she would never wear this

Something's off for me, but Emily looks cute in these and I think the only thing throwing me off are the shoes. Ok, yeah, I covered up the shoes and I liked this

These are Molly's and they're actually acceptable, but I always see shoes like that in the store and shudder at the thought of wearing them

It's a onesie, but it's missing the feet. I love this color for Kit though, and the coral complements it perfectly

This historical nightgown is lovely, and the collar isn't choking her, so... I love

Oh, love this, but hate the pink ribbon. The embroidery is cute though

Felicity did it better than Elizabeth, and I adore bonnets

Darling, I love the embroidered flowers and the lace, the only thing wrong is the bow in the corner

There is nothing wrong with these, but they're very forgettable. I don't like the length of the pants either

Wow, Josephina's hair is long. And again, red was totally her color, not this tangerine orange

The final five!! This is where they get really good. I love it. The only thing wrong with it is the little elastic cuff at the wrist, otherwise perfection

Addy's nightgown is absolutely adorable and it's only this low because of the shoes

I love these soooooooooooooooooooooooooo much!!!!!!!!!!!! It was so hard to choose between the final three!!!! Again, only thing wrong is the shoes! And not even the shoes as a whole, just the daisy decal on the shoes!!

This is so freakin' adorable and I don't know why I don't have this yet!!! AHHHH! I love it!!

This means the best nightgown award, the creme-de-la-creme, the winner of the pj showdown is...

Drumroll please!!

Oh. My. Goodness. I love these to death. The shirt, the shorts, the TINKERBELL SHOES! AG didn't mess up the shoes! I love it! I love it! I love it! Congrats Melody, you have won!!!!!!!!!

If you made it to the end of this post... Wow. Thanks.

Love and sweet dreams, Ev